White House aide Natalie Harp could be barred from posting official announcements on President Donald Trump's Truth Social account under a proposed remedy in a federal lawsuit challenging a subscription service that gives paying customers early access to selected posts.

The Intercept and the Freedom of the Press Foundation outlined the proposal in a Nov. 13 filing in New York. It would also cover deputy chief of staff Dan Scavino and potentially other White House employees who publish presidential communications through the account.

No posting restriction has been imposed. U.S. District Judge J. Paul Oetken is scheduled to hear arguments Thursday, Nov. 19, on the administration's request to dismiss the case, rather than issue a scheduled ruling on the proposed ban.

The organizations primarily want the court to stop Trump from publishing official announcements through Truth Social, or authorizing others to do so, while the paid service remains operational. Restricting staff would be an alternative if the judge determines he cannot directly limit the president's posting activity.

Their lawsuit, filed Aug. 12, challenges Truth API, a service launched Aug. 1 by Trump Media & Technology Group. The company is not a defendant.

Reuters reported in October that Bloomberg and two trading firms had subscribed to faster access, with subscriptions costing as much as $100,000 a month. The plaintiffs argue that advance delivery of presidential statements gives subscribers an advantage over journalists and members of the public.

The concern is particularly acute for announcements involving tariffs, military action and other government decisions that can move financial markets. Automated trading firms can respond rapidly to new information, making even a brief difference in delivery time potentially valuable.

The plaintiffs contend that Trump should not be able to "sell a head start" on official information. They also argue that using Truth Social exclusively for certain announcements helps generate demand for the subscription service.

Harp and Scavino feature in the proposed remedy because they regularly help publish posts on Trump's behalf, according to the filing. The requested restriction concerns those official duties, not their personal social media activity. Neither is accused of personally selling subscriptions or receiving service revenue.

Harp, Trump's executive assistant, joined his team in 2022 after working at One America News and frequently accompanies him at official engagements. Scavino has helped manage Trump's online communications for years.

The lawsuit names both aides, Trump, the Executive Office of the President and the White House Office. It alleges violations of First and Fifth Amendment protections, claims the administration disputes.

The administration argues that the court cannot meaningfully remedy the plaintiffs' alleged injuries and that the subscription arrangement does not violate constitutional protections.

"They are wrong twice over," the plaintiffs responded, maintaining that an order directed at staff could reduce the number of official announcements reaching paying customers first.