President Donald Trump has privately grown frustrated with Vice President JD Vance for blaming Republicans' midterm defeat on the Iran war without also defending the decision to launch it, while praising Secretary of State Marco Rubio as a potential 2028 presidential contender, The New York Times reported Wednesday.
The disagreement concerns how the administration explains its biggest electoral setback. Trump has acknowledged that the conflict hurt Republicans, but wants Vance to affirm that attacking Iran was justified despite the political cost, according to people familiar with his remarks.
Rubio has consistently offered that defense, arguing that Trump confronted a national security threat even though doing so was unpopular. Trump's favorable comments about him add uncertainty to a succession contest in which many Republicans have viewed Vance as the likely frontrunner.
Neither man has announced a campaign.
Vance put the war at the center of his post-election assessment after Democrats captured both chambers of Congress and won Senate races in traditionally Republican states, including Texas, Kansas, Mississippi and Alaska.
"The reason we lost is the war," he wrote on social media.
Trump initially responded with apparent agreement. "I think it's largely true," he told reporters. Over the following two weeks, however, he complained to aides and allies that Vance's account lacked a clear endorsement of the military campaign, the Times reported.
The president also voiced that criticism publicly, saying Vance should have "made one other statement."
"If you had it to do again, would you do it again? The answer is yes," Trump said.
Rubio's response to the same electoral reckoning has aligned more closely with Trump's position. Asked about Vance's assessment earlier this month, the secretary of state said the president had "identified a very real threat" in Iran and defended confronting it as necessary for American security.
Vance rejected suggestions of a policy split during a Fox News interview this week.
"I think there's no daylight between the president or any other senior member of the administration," he said.
Asked about a presidential campaign, Vance said he would decide next year. "I haven't made a decision," he said. "We'll figure it out sometime next year."
People close to the vice president told the Times that he remained undecided, citing his young family and his assessment of whether he could win. His fourth child was born in July.
Reports emerged Nov. 5 that Rubio was considering leaving the administration to pursue a presidential bid. He has since told reporters he would no longer discuss 2028 "in any form or fashion."
Preparations around both men nevertheless appear to be advancing. The Independent reported Monday that Vance allies and political operatives had begun preliminary planning or assessing possible campaigns. Three Republican donors also expressed hope that Rubio would run, the newspaper said.
A recent Reuters/Ipsos poll found that 45% of Republican voters considered Rubio an "excellent" presidential candidate, compared with 43% for Vance. Those ratings measure respondents' assessments of each man, rather than their choice between them in a nomination contest.