Meghan Markle's latest venture into lifestyle television has sparked sharp criticism from Meghan McCain, who labeled the upcoming Netflix series With Love, Meghan as "utterly tone deaf" and "out of touch." The Duchess of Sussex unveiled the trailer for the series on Instagram this week, only to face backlash for what critics, including McCain, view as an ill-timed and overly curated portrayal of luxury living.
McCain, the daughter of the late Senator John McCain, took to X (formerly Twitter) to voice her disapproval. "I was originally a Meghan Markle supporter. I thought she was cool, stylish, and refreshing," McCain wrote. "Like the rest of the world, my opinion changed when she disrespected the royal family. Now that she wants to be American again instead of British aristocracy, what she seems to forget is Americans want real, raw, uncensored. All of this, even in the trailer, is highly curated, produced, and out of touch."
The Netflix series, set to premiere on January 15, features Markle hosting episodes that blend cooking, gardening, and homemaking tips with candid conversations alongside guests such as Mindy Kaling and chef Roy Choi. Produced by Markle and Prince Harry's Archewell Productions, the show promises "practical how-to's" and a "playful" approach to creating beauty in everyday life. Markle described the series on Instagram as an "inspiring" take on lifestyle programming, stating, "I hope you love the show as much as I loved making it."
McCain, however, dismissed the premise as disconnected from the realities faced by many Americans. "There have been two terror attacks in two days, major wars raging, and Americans can't pay for groceries," McCain posted. "We are a country in rage, uncertainty, and intensity right now. This concept is ill-advised. I would have told her to do a show helping bring fresh food to food deserts in low-income neighborhoods. Do something to help people instead of your ego. This is why the world doesn't like you-nothing else. Just completely and utterly tone deaf to the moment."
The eight-episode series, directed by Michael Steed, is part of Markle and Prince Harry's $100 million deal with Netflix, which has already produced projects such as Harry & Meghan and Polo. While Netflix has not responded to McCain's remarks, the trailer features Markle baking pastries, harvesting honey in her backyard, and engaging in conversations with friends. The portrayal of an idyllic and luxurious lifestyle has drawn scrutiny for its perceived unattainability.
McCain's criticism is not isolated. The series arrives at a time of heightened economic strain in the United States, where inflation has left many Americans struggling with basic expenses like groceries and housing. Critics argue that the timing of such a polished and seemingly extravagant series is poorly aligned with the challenges many viewers face.
"This is why the world doesn't like you," McCain added, pointing to what she sees as Markle's lack of connection with the broader public. She suggested that Markle could have opted for a show with a more tangible impact, such as addressing food insecurity or providing support to underserved communities.
Despite the backlash, Markle appears steadfast in her vision for With Love, Meghan. The show's official description from Netflix emphasizes its focus on embracing "playfulness over perfection" and aims to inspire viewers to create beauty even in unexpected places. Markle's supporters have praised her for pursuing creative projects that reflect her personality and interests.
